Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
About Me Premium Member Wise Ass da-debate-crewUnited States Recent Activity Deviant for 2 Years
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 1 Deviation
1 Comment
2,133 Pageviews

The dA Debate Crew

Tue Jan 2, 2007, 3:00 AM
  • Listening to: Penelope (acoustic) by Saosin.
  • Reading: Time Magazine.
  • Watching: CNN.
  • Playing: The fiddle.
  • Eating: Broken spirits.
  • Drinking: Blood of innocents.
Welcome. You've stumbled upon the dA debate club.

Let's go over a few ground rules:

:bulletred: Be courteous to all other members of the crew. We are all subject to the etiquette policy.

:bulletred: It should be obvious, but the idiocy of the common man should never be underestimated, so I'll mention this: be prepared to debate. If you want to state your opinions and never have them attacked, questioned or otherwise discussed, you do not belong here.

:bulletred: Be prepared to debate properly. There is a fine line between flaming and debating. Do not cross it. No debate should ever become a bitchfight.
There is a fine line between flaming and debating. Do not cross it.

There. Not so difficult, are they? Now, let's go over the purpose of the crew:

dA Debate Crew is

:bulletblue: A place to have debates with others interested in debating. Sounds obvious, but we've gone over the dangers of assuming everyone has common sense.

:bulletblue: A place to rationally explain your views and explore the views of others.

:bulletblue: A place to discuss current events and other political or social issues.

dA Debate Crew is not

:bulletblue: A place to have silly arguments totally outside the parameters of debate.

:bulletblue: A place bursting with friendly agreement.

:bulletblue: A place to spam, troll or otherwise affect negatively.

Loose ends I'd like to stress:

There are a few rules to the sort of debate that I'd like to see here. Typically, Lincoln-Douglas debate is the accepted format for one-on-one debate. However, it's a bit impractical for usage on the internet, so I'd like only to retain a few of its canon principles:

1.) Be prepared to back up your contentions (arguments) with credible evidence. Anecdotal evidence is not credible.

2.) Keep the insults to yourself. Calling someone a fool might (unfortunately) be understandable at times, but 'motherfucker' and the like can be left to other venues. Responding to a post with only insults, no matter how based you may see them in reality, does not count as a proper rebuttal.

3.) Typically, someone in the debate will lose. Look at it as a learning experience and don't harbour hard feelings. Don't sulk, don't bitch, don't whine. Typing 'I stand corrected' is not a difficult thing to do.

4.) If someone concedes to you, be polite and accept it. Belittling someone after a concession has been made is unfair and abusive.

5.) 'I'M ALLOWED TO HAVE MY OWN OPINION' is not a proper rebuttal, either. Those who use it automatically lose the debate.

That's about it for rules and regulation. I, =Unch am serving as the president of the club. There are also Senators, who have 'mod-like' powers. This means if they tell you you're outside the rules, you need to take heed.

:bulletpurple:The following explains how the club works.:bulletpurple:

The submissions to be discussed come from the club members. You, the club member, are free to note a submission for debate at any time, and I'll post them as a deviation. The debate will follow in the form of comments, obviously. Here is an example of a proper submission:

Topic: Green Apples

My opinion of green apples is ________. I think green apples are ________ based on ____. This claim is based on the evidence submitted to the London Journal of Apples by a Dr. Appleface. I also believe that green apples are ________ based on the ideas of Mr. Applehead: _________. Red apples seem to be _______, as do yellow. Typically, green apples are much more ________, as is proven by the American Apple Report. Blah, blah, blah.


Here is an example of an unacceptable submission:

Topic: America

omg i h8 america so much omfg wtf bush iz an idiot hes totaly a dictater wtf anarky rox lol


Having said all that, please note your worthy submissions to me on both this account and =Unch, as it would be assured to reach me that way.

How to join:

1.) Add *da-debate-crew onto your watch list and link it in your signature. When I see the addition, I'll add you as well.


That's all. Welcome again; please enjoy your stay.

Current Members:

President:

Senators:

Citizens:




:bulletblue::bulletred:NEWS::bulletred::bulletblue:

We have a chat! [link] Step in some time.

Also: The NFL topic for January and Frebruary is: Corporations ought to be held to the same moral standards as individuals.

deviantID

Devious Info

  • Interests: Debate.
  • Favourite movie: Apocalypse Now.
  • Skin of choice: n00b.
  • Favourite game: Pokemon Stadium.
  • Favourite gaming platform: Nintendo 64.
  • Personal Quote: "Concede. Now."
  • Tools of the Trade: Wit, logic, substantial evidence.

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Comments


Flagged as Spam
Flagged as Spam
Flagged as Spam
Flagged as Spam
Flagged as Spam
:icondesudesuplz:
Desu is a master debater ~desu
:iconp-u-r-i-n:


--
Before anyone gets the wrong idea about my new avatar, the bird is dancing.

Site Map